Skip to content

Head to head

Earth Rated Lavender 120 vs Amazon Basics 900 Unscented (2027)

The everyday premium roll against the bulk bundle: Earth Rated lavender 120 versus Amazon Basics 900 unscented on thickness, scent, count and value.

TGBy TrueGear Research TeamIndependent editorial teamLast updated How we researchResearch-based assessment · Dog Poop Bags
Specs verified against manufacturer docs
No paid placements
Independently funded by readers
Updated 2026-11-03
Earth Rated Lavender 120 vs Amazon Basics 900 Unscented (2027) featured graphic

What owners report

Most praised
  • The lavender scent makes carrying a tied bag to the next bin noticeably less unpleasant on long walks
  • The 15-micron film feels substantial in hand, and owners say it resists poking through on rough ground
  • The rolls thread into the dispensers owners already own without jamming or tearing at the perforation
Common complaints
  • The lavender fragrance reads as strong to some owners, especially when a fresh roll is opened indoors
  • Tying a knot one-handed while holding a pulling dog takes practice with a handle-free bag
  • The 120-count box empties fast in two-dog households, turning a routine reorder into a frequent chore

What owners report

Most praised
  • The 900-count box ends the cycle of running out mid-week, which multi-dog owners mention first
  • The included dispenser clips on and works from the first walk, with no separate accessory hunt
  • The plain unscented film suits owners whose dogs sneeze or fuss at perfumed bags
Common complaints
  • Without handles, owners with stiff fingers find the knot-close fiddly on cold mornings
  • The black film makes it hard to see whether the bag is fully intact before use
  • Storing a 900-count box is a small furniture problem in flats with little cupboard room

Our recommendation

Choose on what you value per bag versus per box. Earth Rated gives a thicker stated film, recycled-plastic content and a lavender scent that helps on the carry, in a 120-count box that suits one or two dogs. Amazon Basics gives nine hundred unscented bags with a dispenser and leash clip, at the budget tier, for homes that would burn through the small box in weeks. If your bags tear, or scent matters to you, take Earth Rated. If you run out constantly, or walk several dogs, take Amazon Basics and stop thinking about reordering.

Thickness and size

Earth Rated states 15 microns, the thick end of the refill class, in a 13 x 9 in bag. Amazon Basics states the same 13 x 9 in size but no thickness figure, so its film should be treated as unmeasured. For owners whose bags have torn, the stated figure is a real reason to choose Earth Rated; for owners whose bags never tear, the size match means the difference never shows.

Scent and material

Earth Rated is lavender-scented and made with 65% post-consumer recycled plastic, per the maker. Amazon Basics is unscented and makes no recycled-content claim in its listing. Scent divides owners, so this is a taste call, but the recycled content is a factual edge for Earth Rated that eco-minded owners will weigh.

Count and completeness

Amazon Basics wins outright: 900 bags against 120, with a dispenser and leash clip in the box against a refill-only box. A one-dog household buys Earth Rated roughly six times as often as Amazon Basics, and a multi-dog household far more. The counterpoint is storage: a 900-count box needs shelf space, while a 120-count box fits anywhere.

Close and format

Both are handle-free refill rolls that close with a knot and fit standard dispensers, so there is no format difference to decide. Owners who want a handle close should look at Earth Rated's own handle bags instead, which keep the brand and scent while fixing the knot problem.

Choose Earth Rated Lavender Refill Rolls, 120 Bags if…

  • Your bags have torn before and you want a stated thickness
  • Lavender scent helps you on the carry to the bin
  • Recycled-plastic content matters to your purchase
  • One or two dogs, where 120 bags lasts a reasonable while

Choose Amazon Basics Unscented Waste Bags with Dispenser, 900 if…

  • You run out of bags constantly and want the problem gone
  • You walk several dogs or run a dog-walking round
  • Unscented suits your dogs or your clients better
  • You need a dispenser and leash clip in the same box

Questions, answered

Which is better for a first-time dog owner?

Amazon Basics 900, because it includes the dispenser and leash clip, so nothing else is needed. Earth Rated is the better second purchase, once you know your dispenser, your scent preference and whether your bags tear.

Is Earth Rated worth the higher tier?

For owners whose bags tear or who value recycled content and scent, yes. For owners whose bags never tear and who dislike fragrance, the Amazon Basics bundle delivers the same size and a far bigger count at the budget tier.

Can I use both?

Many owners do: Earth Rated rolls on the leash for the scent and thickness, Amazon Basics rolls as the bulk reserve that keeps the house stocked. Since both are standard refill rolls, they share dispensers without any adjustment.

Every guide on Dog Poop Bags16 pages